|
"P.C.B."—"(1)What
is the possessive form of the expression 'some one else'?
(2) I learned a rule, 'the possessive is formed by adding
s, except to plural nouns ending in s,
to which the apostrophe only should be added.' Does not
this rule apply to proper nouns like 'Jones',
'James,' etc.?"
(1) " Some one else's
" is good usage, but many prefer to treat such expressions
simply as elliptical, as, the umbrella is somebody's
else (i.e., other than the person previously mentioned).
The subject is covered by the Standard Dictionary on p.
588, under "else."
(2) "Some words ending in a sibilant omit the s
of the possessive to avoid the disagreeable repetition
of a hissing sound. The rules for the possessive followed
by the Standard Dictionary are: (a) To singular monosyllablic
nouns ending in a sibilant sound, as s, .x, ce,
se, or dental ge, add the apostrophe and
s, except when the following word begins with
a sibilant sound; as, "James's reign" ; "Jones's
hat"; "a fox' skin." (b) Singular dissyllabic
nouns ending in a sibilant sound add the apostrophe and
s, unless the sibilant is preceded by another
sibilant or the last syllable is unaccented ; as, "Porus
' defeat" ; "Moses' face"; "Jesus'
disciples"; "Hortense's fate." (c) Singular
polysyllabic nouns ending in a sibilant sound add the
apostrophe and s only when a principal or secondary
accent falls on the last syllable
as "Boniface's mistake"; "Quackenbos's
Rhetoric," etc.
|